RSS Feed

Political Gladiators

Posted on

When it comes to the failings of our current political system, I can sum up the problem in three words:

Americans love conflict.

Really, that’s what it all boils down to. Maybe the world in general loves conflict, but I can only speak from an American perspective… and I know Americans are drawn to a good fight.

An adversarial system only works when the focus is on solving problems. Our political system focuses on the players and the fight. We don’t have an adversarial system. Politics in America is a sporting event.

Our focus is on the battle. Our focus is on the winners and losers. The actual problems are secondary.

And it’s our fault that this has happened. Hell, we made it happen.

We’re drawn to the conflict. We love the fight. The politicians know it and the news networks know it.

Just look at the programming on every news network in America. It’s always based on conflict, not resolution. When they have a panel of people discussing an issue, they never have a group of men and women discussing rational solutions to a problem. Instead, they have a group of entrenched fundamentalists who fight with each other. They use political gladiators.

Fox News isn’t popular because it’s conservative. Fox News is popular because it manufactures conflict. MSNBC doesn’t have viewers because its liberal. It has viewers who tune in for the “spirited debate”, which translates to “The fight’s on!” CNN recently brought back Crossfire, because people like to watch combatants duke it out. It’s good TV.

Compromise is boring. Reasonable solutions are boring. Figuring out how to get along… is boring!

But a good fight… now, that’s worth paying attention to! Every election is about winners and losers. We pick our horses and we watch the election results hoping our horses win.

We like the battle. We like the glory of victory!

And because of that, there’s no real incentive for our politicians to work together and come up with solutions. They know what their constituents don’t really want compromise. They want victory.

And the “news”… why would they put on reasonable people who are willing to compromise when they know full well that doing so will cost them viewers?

Politics shouldn’t be about winners and losers. It shouldn’t be about the fight. It shouldn’t be a sporting event.

Politics should be about solving problems, and that is something that simply does not happen in our current political environment.

And it’s our fault that it has come to this. They’re only doing what they know we want.

As long as winning is more important that fixing our problems, we will never see genuine progress.

— Jerry


3 responses »

  1. The fighting is systemic to adversarial politics, however only recently has it been reduced to all out battles, disregarding what is in the public interest. No longer is compromise a political alternative. For that, we are all losers.

    • Totally, Bill. The fighting – in and of itself – isn’t the problem. Our founding fathers had some pretty epic battles themselves. The difference is, for them the fight was a means to an end. The fight was a necessary part of finding a solution to a problem. Today, the fighting is the end. It’s the fight that attracts us. It has become our entertainment instead of a necessary part of a problem-solving system.

      Americans watch political discussion shows for the fights, not for the problems or the solutions.

      Politics really has become a gladiatorial sporting event where we back an opponent and nothing that opponent does or says will deter us from backing him.

  2. Pingback: Turning Off the Next Generation of Politicians | pundit from another planet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Progressive Culture | Scholars & Rogues

Arts & literature, pop culture, media, photography, sports and climate


freedom isn't free

Jim's Senior News

Seniors In Motion Stay Young

Your Face Is Politics

Intelligent discussion of politics without all the PC nonsense

%d bloggers like this: